The Crime You Don’t Know You’re a Victim Of: Medical Identity Theft

By Dr. Karen Reynolds, DHA, MBA, BCPA – KareKo Well® • October 22, 2025

Signs You Might Be a Victim

Medical identity theft happens when someone uses your personal or insurance information to receive medical care, prescriptions, or equipment under your name.


It might be an outsider who hacked a system.


It might even be someone you trusted — a caregiver, employee, or medical office that didn’t secure your records properly.


Once that information is out there, it’s nearly impossible to control where it goes.



What is Medical Identify Theft?

Medical identity theft happens when someone uses your personal or insurance information to receive medical care, prescriptions, or equipment under your name.


It might be an outsider who hacked a system.


It might even be someone you trusted — a caregiver, employee, or medical office that didn’t secure your records properly.


Once that information is out there, it’s nearly impossible to control where it goes.



Why It's So Dangerous

We expect our personal information to be safe inside the walls of healthcare — but what happens when it’s not?


Medical identity theft is one of the most silent and devastating crimes. It doesn’t just steal your name or your Social Security number — it steals your health story. And most people don’t find out until it’s too late.



A surprise bill. A denied claim. A prescription you never filled. That’s when it hits you.


Signs You Might Be a Victim

  • You receive bills for medical services you never had

  • Your insurance claim is denied for reaching a “benefit limit” you didn’t use.

  • Your Explanation of Benefits (EOB) lists unfamiliar doctors or hospitals.

  • You’re contacted about medical debt that doesn’t belong to you.


If even one of these sounds familiar — it’s time to dig deeper


🛡️ How to protect Yourself

Here are some simple steps that protect you from becoming the next silent victim:

  1. Review your medical bills and EOBs regularly. Treat them like your bank statements.

  2. Guard your Medicare and insurance card. Never share it casually or post photos of it online.

  3. Ask your insurance provider for an annual benefits summary. It helps you spot errors early.

  4. Keep all medical documents in a safe, HIPAA-compliant vault — like KareKo Well’s secure client portal.

  5. Work with a certified patient advocate if you suspect something’s off. An expert can help trace and dispute errors before they snowball.


Final Thoughts

Medical identity theft is one of those things we don’t think about — until we have to.

By the time the damage is done, it can take years to untangle the confusion and correct your records.


That’s why awareness matters.
At KareKo Well®, I help families protect their health, their privacy, and their peace of mind before a crisis happens.
Because prevention isn’t paranoia — it’s power.


Next time on Hidden Until It HITS You!

“When Your Doctor Retires—And You Didn’t See It Coming”

Learn how to protect your continuity of care and ensure your records, prescriptions, and trust don’t disappear overnight.


By Karen Reynolds June 21, 2023
Dr. Karen will be a Keynote at The Seven Figure Boss Summit July 9, 2023. Register Today!
Kare Well LLC website
By Dr. Karen Reynolds, DHA, MBA October 2, 2020
Today we launch our website, www.karewell.org! When starting out, building a website myself was quite daunting. For many entrepreneurs, we are the do all for the company. Quickly learning that I was out of my element and contacted thestackgrp.com to help build our new site.
KareKo Well Services
By Dr. Karen Reynolds, DHA, MBA October 2, 2020
Managing health and finances are interconnected. 2020 and the Covid 19 Pandemic has truly peeled the layers back and brought us front and center with getting our affairs in order. This is an uncomfortable space for some. Here at KareKo Well through our advocacy and consulting services, we strive to assist you with decision support to offer peace of mind.
By Dr. Karen Reynolds, DHA, MBA October 2, 2020
The health system is a complexity of business practices and care delivery. Navigating it to ensure the best care options can be overwhelming. Through decision-support, education, and collaborative resources, KareKo Well inspires and empowers more pro-active approaches to improve experiences within the health system and beyond. Whether we provide guidance on navigating the system, assist with communication, aligning resources, or offer support for those end-of-life conversations with your family, our goal is to be an essential component of your healthcare team.